CASE NO. 

PARTICULARS

STATUS OF CASE

92-001

NICOLAS E. NERI -V.- PEDRO P. ROMUALDO   / LONE DISTRICT CAMIGUIN

The Tribunal Resolved to DENY Protestant Neri's Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit. This denial is FINAL.

92-002

FIDELITO A. AVANZADO -V.- ORLANDO B. FUA   / LONE DISTRICT SIQUIJOR

The PROTEST of Protestant Avanzado is DISMISSED...The Tribunal declares that Protestee Orlando B. Fua,... is the duly elected Representative for the Lone District of Siquijor

92-003

HADJI HUSSIN T. LOONG -V.- BENSAUDI D. TULAWIE   /  1ST DISTRICT SULU

The Tribunal AFFIRMS the proclamation of Protestee Bensaudi Tulawie and DECLARES him to be the elected Representative....having obtained a plurality of One Thousand One Hundred Eighty Eight (1,188) votes...

Protestant Loong's Motion for Partial Reconsideration and Protestee Tulawie's plea for recomputation are DENIED WITH FINALITY.

92-004

ROLLEO L. IGNACIO -V.- RENATO V. LEVISTE   / 1ST DISTRICT OF ORIENTAL MINDORO

It appearing that the Petition of Protest is filed on May 28, 1992 or eleven (11) days after Protestee's proclamation on May 17, 1992, the instant case is hereby DISMISSED.

Protestant's Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED with FINALITY.

92-005 

ARTURO DUBONGCO -V.- RAUL DAZA   / 1ST DISTRICT NORTHERN SAMAR

The Petition in the above entitled case is hereby DISMISSED with cost against the Protestant.

92-006

ANTONIO D. LACDAO -V.- RALPH G. RECTO   / 4TH DISTRICT BATANGAS

'in view of the failure of Protestant Lacdao to diligently and properly prosecute and substantiate his Protest and in line with the constitutionally mandated task  of the Tribunal to resolve electoral protests with utmost promptitude and dispatch. The Tribunal Resolve to DISMISS this case.

92-007 

SALVACION Z. PEREZ -V.- EXEQUIEL B. JAVIER   / LONE DISTRICT ANTIQUE

The Tribunal declares that Protestee Exequiel B. Javier is the duly elected Representative of the Lone District of Antique with a plurality of six hundred five (605) votes over Protestant Salvacion Perez.

92-008 

SENFORIANO B. ALTERADO -V.- MANUEL M. GARCIA  / 2ND DISTRICT DAVAO CITY

This Protest is DISMISSED and the Tribunal hereby AFFIRMS  the proclamation of Protestee Manuel M. Garcia.

Protestant' Motion for Reconsideration is likwise DENIED WITH FINALITY.

92-009 

ROY PILANDO -V.- VICTOR DOMIGUEZ   / 

This Resolution is FINAL AND EXECUTORY.

'Acting on the pleading, the Tribunal GRANT and APPROVE the withdrawal of Protest and Counter Protest prayed by both parties.

92-010

EDGARDO T. CUNETA -V.- JOVITO O. CLAUDIO  /  LONE DISTRICT PASAY CITY

In view of Petitioner Cuneta's inability to discharge the onus of proof required of him as party-petitioner... the instant petition for Quo Warranto is hereby DISMISSED.

92-011

AMADOR L. SIMANDO -V.- ARNULFO P. FUENTEBELLA  / 3RD DISTRICT CAMARINES SUR

This Protest is DISMISSED. The Tribunal  hereby declares Protestee Fuentebella the duly elected Representative for the 3rd District of Camarines Sur with a plurality of One Thousand Forty One (1,041) votes over the Protestant.

Protestant' Motion for Reconsideration is likewise DENIED WITH FINALITY.

92-012 / 92-013

JOSE CRUZ HERNANDEZ  -V.- MANUEL REYES SANCHEZ (92-012)

BENJAMIN DE LEON,JR -V.- MANUEL REYES SANCHEZ (92-013)

1ST DISTRICT RIZAL

Respondent Manuel Reyes Sanchez is hereby adjudged and declared NOT a citizen of the Philippines and is accordingly DISQUALIFIED.... and is hereby ordered to VACATE his office

92-014

MARIO E. HISULER -V.- MACABANGKIT B. LANTO   /  2ND DISTRICT LANAO DEL NORTE

"judgement is hereby rendered:"1. ANNULING and SETTING ASIDE the proclamation of Protestee Lanto: 2.DECLARING Protestant Hisuler as the duly elected Representative, Second Legislative District Lanao del Norte, for having obtained, after due revision and appreciation, a plurality of Five Hundred Seventy Nine (579) votes  over Protestee Lanto.

92-015

WILLIAM F. CLAVER -V.- ELIAS K. BULUT   / LONE DISTRICT KALINGA-APAYAO

For failure or Protestant Claver to submit sufficient evidence to warrant the reliefs sought, this case is hereby DISMISSED.

92-016

LEOPOLDO E. SAN BUENAVENTURA -V.- CELSO O. BAGUIO  / 2ND DISTRICT CAMARINES SUR

This Protest is DISMISSED. The Tribunal  hereby declares Protestee Celso O. Baguio the duly elected Representative for the 2nd District of Camarines Sur with a plurality of Four Thousand One HUndred Twenty Four (4,124) votes over the Protestant.

Protestant' Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED WITH FINALITY.

92-017

JESUS T. TANCHANCO -V.- TERESA AQUINO ORETA  / LONE DISTRICT MALABON-NAVOTAS

The Election Protest of Protestant Tanchanco is DISMISSED and the Tribunal AFFIRMS the proclamation of Protestee Aquino...

92-018

ARDEN S. ANNI -V.- ASANI S. TAMMANG  / 2ND DISTRICT SULU

Petitioner Anni having failed to submit sufficient evidence to prove that Respondent Tammang committed any violation of the Omnibus Election Code that would warrant his disqualification, this case is hereby DISMISSED.

92-019

AUGUSTO L. SYJUCO,JR. -V.- JOKER P. ARROYO   /  LONE DISTRICT MAKATI

"judgement is hereby rendered:"1. ANNULING and SETTING ASIDE the proclamation of Protestee Arroyo: 2.DECLARING Protestant Syjuco,Jr. as the duly elected Representative, Lone District Makati, for having obtained, after due revision and appreciation, a plurality of 1,565 votes  over Protestee Arroyo.

92-020

ALAWADIN T. BANDON -V.- NUR G. JAAFAR  / LONE DISTRICT TAWI TAWI

For failure of Protestant Bandon to deposit the required amount needed for the collection of ballot boxes necessary....the Petition is hereby DISMISSED.

92-021

ARMANDO LIZASO -V.- LEANDRO B. VERCELES  / 

Acting upon the Joint Motion to Withdraw Election Protest and Counter Protest... the said Motion is hereby granted...

The Protest and Counter Protest in the instant case is hereby DISMISSED.

92-022

GERONIMO S. REYES,JR, -V.- FRANCISCO K. MAMBA   /  3RD DISTRICT CAGAYAN

The Tribunal hereby renders judgment UPHOLDING and AFFIRMING the proclamation of Protestee Mamba and DECLARING him to be the duly elected Representative...having obtained a plurality of Four Hundred Thirty One (431) votes....

92-023

FRANCIS PANCRATIUS N. PANGILINAN -V.- FELICIANO BELMONTE, JR.   / QUEZON CITY

In his Motion to Withdraw Petition, Protestant Pangilinan prays for leave to Withdraw his Protest.

The Motion is GRANTED, and the Protest is considered WITHDRAWN.

92-024

CEFERINO T. ONG -V.- HILARION RAMIRO,JR.  /

Under Rule 32 of the Revised Rules of theTribunal, the cash deposit for the Protest must be paid within ten (10) days for the date of filing....no deposit has been made by the Protestant.

"the instant case hereby DISMISSED."

92-025

 RENATO M. UNICO -V.- EMMANUEL B. PIMENTEL  / LONE DISTRICT CAMARINES NORTE

The Tribunal DISMISSED the instant Protest, AFFIRMED the proclamtion of Protestee Pimentel and DECLARED him to be the duly elected Representative for the Lone District of 
Camarines Norte.

92-026

FRANCO LOYOLA -V.- RENATO P. DRAGON  / 2ND DISTRICT CAVITE

For failure of Protestant Loyola to submit sufficient evidence to warrant the relief sought, this case is hereby DISMISSED.

"finding no cogent arguments in Protestant Loyola's Motion for Reconsideration  which would warrant.... the Motion is hereby DENIED with finality.

92-027

PALA TAIB DIPATUAN -V.- MOHAMAD ALI DIMAPORO   /  2ND DISTRICT LANAO DEL SUR

The Tribunal hereby DISMISSES the instant Protest and AFFIRMS the proclamation of Protestee Dimaporo as the duly elected Representative of 2nd District of Lanao del Sur with a plurality of One Hundred Thirty One (131) votes....

The Tribunal Resolved to DENY WITH FINALITY the Motion for Reconsideration of Protestant Dipatuan...

92-028

JOSE ONG,JR. -V.- WILMAR P. LUCERO  / 2ND DISTRICT NORTHERN SAMAR

"judgment is hereby rendered:  a. DISMISSING, b.  AFFIRMING AND CONFIRMING the election and proclamation of Protestee Lucero as the duly elected Representative of 2nd District of Northern Samar, having obtained the majority of valid votes.... and a plurality of Three Hundred Fifty NIne (359) votes....