Republic of the Philippines
House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal
HRET CASES 2022 - 2025
Case Number
Particulars
Status of the Case
HRET Case No. 22-001 (EP)
ANTONIO M. CAROLINO -V.- MARIA JAMINA KATHERINE AGARAO / 4TH DISTRICT, LAGUNA
Protestant's Petition of Protest dated July 4, 2022 and received by the Tribunal on even date is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
The proclamation of Maria Jamina Katherine Agarao as Member of the House of Representative for the Fourth District of the Province of Laguna is hereby AFFIRMED.
HRET Case No. 22-002 (EP)
JESUS MANUEL SUNTAY -V.- MARVIN RILLO / 4TH DISTRICT, QUEZON CITY
For failure to show reasonable recovery of votes, the election protest is DISMISSED without further proceedings, and the proclamation of Marvin D. Rillo as Member of the House of Representative for the Fourth District of Quezon City is hereby AFFIRMED.
HRET Case No. 22-003 (EP)
HECTORY S. SANCHEZ -V.- EULOGIO R. RODRIGUEZ / LONE DISTRICT, CATANDUANES
The Tribunal GRANTS Protestee's Motion for Reconsideration dated March 23, 2023, REVERSING and SETTING ASIDE Resolution No. 23-006 dated February 23, 2023, DISMISSING HRET Case No. 22-003 (EP), and AFFIRMING the proclamation of Protestee Rodriguez as the winning candidate for Member, of the House of Representative for the Lone District of Catanduanes.
HRET Case No. 22-004 (EP)
RUBY M. SAHALI -V.- DIMSZAR SALI / LONE DISTRICT, TAWITAWI
The instant Petition (Election Protest) dated July 22, 2022 is DISMISSED in accordance with Rule 35 of 2015 Rules of the House of Representatives Electoral Tribunal. Consequently, protestee's Counter-Protest dated November 7, 2022 is likewise DISMISSED.
HRET Case No. 22-005 (QW)
JOANNA C. SUAREZ -V.- REYNANTE U. SUAREZ / 3RD DISTRICT, QUEZON PROVINCE
The instant petition for quo waranto is DISMISSED for lack of merit. Likewise, respondent's compulsory counterclaim for actual and moral damages against petitioner is DISMISSED for lack of merit.
HRET Case No. 22-006 (QW)
EPHRAIM C. GENUINO -V.- RUTH MARIANO HERNANDEZ / 2ND DISTRICT, LAGUNA
The Petition for Quo Warranto dated July 15, 2022 is DISMISSED for being insufficient in form and substance, in accordance to Rule 23 paragraph 1 of 2015 HRET Rules.
HRET Case No. 22-007 (QW)
MARIA BELEN ANDAYA-EUSEBIO -V.- TSUYOSHI ANTHONY G. HORIBATA / 1ST DISTRICT, CAMARINES SUR
GRANTS respodents special and affirmative defenses.... DISMISSED instant petition for Quo Warranto in a Resolution promulgated on September 21, 2023
HRET Case No. 22-008 (EP)
PROSPERO A. PICHAY,JR. -V.- ROMEO S. MOMO / 1ST DISTRICT, SURIGAO DEL SUR
The protestant has a pending Motion for Leave to Refer the Case to the Court En Banc and to Lift the Entry of Judgment has no bearing on the final and executory character of the judgment against him in GR Nos. 211515 and 236288.
The election protest as well as the counter-protest is likewise DISMISSED.
HRET Case No. 22-009 (QW)
LORETO P. BINUYA -V.- MILAGROS A. MAGSAYSAY / UNITED SENIOR CITIZEN PARTYLIST
The instant petition for quo warranto is DISMISSED for lack of merit.
Petitioner's Motion for Reconsideration dated September 28, 2023 is DENIED for lack of merit.
HRET Case No. 22-010 (EP)
ROMEO M. JASLOSJOS,JR. -V.- ROBERTO T. UY,JR. / 1ST DISTRICT ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE
Protestant's Compliance with Manifestation dated Febraury 13, 2025, filed through personal service on even date, informing the Tribunal of Supreme Court En Banc's Resolution dated July 10, 2024 DENYING WITH FINALITY herein protestant's Motion for Reconsideration in the consolidated cases of GR No, 260650 (Roberto "Pinpin" T. Uy,Jr. v. Commission on Elections, et al.)...is NOTED, ACCEPTED and CONSIDERED....